Overview

Located in the heart of Tampa at 235 E Davis Blvd, Islands Pizza Tavern offers a refreshing take on the classic pizza joint experience. This vibrant spot combines a welcoming tavern atmosphere with an eclectic menu that goes beyond just pizza, catering to both families and casual diners looking for a satisfying meal in a relaxed setting.

The true highlight here is the array of carefully crafted handhelds and hearty sandwiches, featuring standout options like the perfectly cooked ribeye steak sandwich and the grilled pesto chicken on a ciabatta bun. Each bite balances quality ingredients with thoughtful flavor combinations, making these handhelds an excellent complement or alternative to their pizza offerings.

Salads at Islands Pizza Tavern reflect the same commitment to freshness and variety. The Cobb and Greek salads incorporate fresh greens, grilled chicken or shrimp, and vibrant Mediterranean flavors, providing a lighter, yet equally satisfying choice for those seeking balance.

For starters, the appetizer selection serves as a perfect prelude to the main meal. The Bang Bang Shrimp and Grouper Bites bring a touch of coastal flair—either grilled, blackened, or fried—paired with dipping sauces that enhance but never overpower the core taste. Traditional favorites like cheesy bread and mozzarella sticks with marinara keep things familiar and comforting.

The establishment itself strikes a warm, inviting tone, ideal for both casual meetups and family dinners. With its casual tavern vibe combined with attentive service, Islands Pizza Tavern caters to guests who appreciate robust flavors and a laid-back ambiance. Whether stopping in after a day at the nearby waterfront or catching up with friends, the space offers a comfortable setting that encourages lingering over good food and good company.

Overall, Islands Pizza Tavern is not just a pizza restaurant; it is a destination where quality ingredients meet thoughtful preparation, set against the backdrop of Tampa’s lively dining scene. It’s a place where every dish tells a story of flavor, community, and casual indulgence.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Comfort food
Happy-hour drinks
Happy-hour food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Spirits
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine
Atmosphere
Casual

What Customers Say

Lorie Carter
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Where to start??? Their thin crust pizza is so yummy...my fav being the white pizza! Just enough garlic not to be offensive. That said, everything I've had has been fantastic and prices are so reasonable! Love going on Mondays for their $5 burger special. And only an extra $2 for fries that day! Can't. Beat. It. Then there's the service!!! We prefer to eat at the beautiful and newly remodeled bar. That's where we love chatting with Gabby...although all the staff there are so personable and attentive. Definitely, Go Here. Tell them Lorie sent you.
W. A. R. IV
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Chrystina has a pleasant personality...and her attention to details is immpeccable. I would continue to come her just because she is here!
Oxy Jen
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Was door dashing and came to this place. I Ordered a slice while I waited. That supreme pizza slice is thin and well done. Crunchy and large slices. For $6 it was perfect. I heard draft and bottle beers start at $6 also. The liquor bar is also well stocked. The tv rotated a list of everyday specials: Monday $5 burgers, Tuesday 10$ med cheese Wed 75 cent wings Thur 10$ cheese calzones $3 corona bottles on happy hour. Etc etc. Highly recommend for a laid back vibe and well done eats. Cute low key vibe but it was 1 pm on a Tuesday so ;)
JaY Gre
Mar 7,2026
5/5
We had breakfast (????) yes BREAKFAST at Islands pizza, best kept secret in Davis Islands! (Though I shouldn't post this as we didn't have to WAIT for a table was VERY surprised, one of the BEST & priced great! John & (Bobbie.... man will I catch hell waitress, was excellent! Food 5, presentation 5, staff efficiency/accommodating/friendly.... FIVE! We will be going back to Islands Pizza for breakfast AND afternoon/evening PIZZA - Beer!
Teresa Lea B
Mar 7,2026
5/5
This local tavern is clearly a treasure to the community located on Davis island in Tampa, Florida. A friend and I after work hungry and curious, decided to stop by and try it out while driving by. The patrons were having a blast, cheering and chatting, heavily watching their sports on the TVs. Lots of comraderie! We were met by our bartender Caitlin who is new to Tampa and she was genuine, kind , and very experienced. She is happy to see customers happy. Islands Pizza Tavern was spacious, exciting and for the best part for me: the food. I know flavors well and I will say that the grouper bites here are hands down: the best I've EVER had! It had a light crispness and boldly pleasant seasoning with side of tartar sauce. It was so good, I had to let the chef know. I'm still salivating over it, lol. Our main meal was chosen by my friend Ana: Hot Honey soppressatta Pizza as shown by the picture. It was delectable, crust was light and crispy, herbs were fresh, cheese was pliable and fun. Took leftovers home and my sons were raving ! Overall , I can see why this tavern is so successful especially since it's like walking distance for customers on the island. It's nice to see people smile and have fun. Maybe it should be the new place for another "Cheers", lol
Brice Eats
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Marisa is hands down the best bartender ever! No matter what kind of day you’re having, she’ll always put a smile on your face. Her energy, personality, and great service make every visit an awesome experience. Best pizza on the Island!!
Thomas Conely
Mar 7,2026
4/5
Normally one of the best places to stop for slices. Slices were smaller than usual and dried out.. during bucs game!? Too busy in the kitchen maybe? Please work on it. Never slack on the . Chef should approve of everything leaving the kitchen.. we are all serious about pizza, like Tony Bourdain is to Fraugua.. you normally do it right.. Will update this next time i stop. Up or down
Tom Cook
Mar 7,2026
5/5
This is a true gem. The pizza, food, specials whiskey selection and service is exceptional. The setting in Davis Islands Village is easily accessible and a great vibe. Karen served me this evening and provided exceptional service. She made me a great Negroni followed by good draft beer and accompanied by excellent conversation. She’s one of the best bartenders in town for sure. . I highly recommend you visit.

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Tuesday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Wednesday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Thursday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Friday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Saturday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Sunday 07:00 AM - 03:00 AM
Top Picks for You

More in Tampa, Florida, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!